Hi Lutz,\\nThank you so much for sharing this information. As a part of integration with external systems that still use flat files to convert to IDOC, it would help to share the IDOC structures and indicate the changes that have been made with S/4 HANA ( as you mentioned - new fields introduced ). I was unable to find one that indicated the changes to EDI with additional fields. If you can guide me to a document that may have been created / shared, please let me know\\nThanks a lot for your help\",\"author\":\"username\":\"rzalani1\",\"displayName\":\"Rohit Zalani\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"parentAuthor\":\"username\":\"lutzi3\",\"displayName\":\"Lutz Rosenpflanzer\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"id\":13737202,\"creationDate\":1665672592000,\"activeRevisionId\":14281409,\"lastActivity\":1665672592000,\"parentId\":13734441,\"originalParentId\":13732350,\"likeCount\":1,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"depth\":0,\"attachments\":[],\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"relations\":\"canReport\":false,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"canEdit\":false,\"canUseDelete\":false,\"isLiked\":false,\"type\":\"comment\",\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"canConvertToAnswer\":false,\"canBeModerated\":false,\"canViewRevisions\":false,\"score\":1,\"showInReply\":false,\"reported\":false,\"canCancelReport\":false,\"canDelete\":false,\"canVoteDownOrCancel\":false,\"canComment\":false,\"canViewReports\":false,\"isCurrentUserAuthor\":false,\"liked\":false,\"moderatorComment\":false}]},\"13734567\":\"rootParentId\":13734567,\"commentsCount\":1,\"comments\":[\"body\":\"Hi Joachim,\\nThank you for your response. As I responded to Lutz, it would be useful for integration teams to share the new fields ( or any field level changes ) that may have been made to SAP's EDI IDOC structures so that these can be shared with these teams. As you suggested, the Custom Code Migration will let you know the changes that you may have to do, but if there are new fields / field changes that may have been made to EDI IDOC structures, it would help to have that information included in the documentation so that teams can assess any impacts to external systems / integrations.\\nRegards\\nRohit Zalani\",\"author\":\"username\":\"rzalani1\",\"displayName\":\"Rohit Zalani\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"parentAuthor\":\"username\":\"vonhunnius\",\"displayName\":\"Joachim von Hunnius\",\"groupIcons\":[\"name\":\"employee\",\"title\":\"This user is an SAP Employee\",\"priority\":21],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"id\":13737203,\"creationDate\":1665672776000,\"activeRevisionId\":14281410,\"lastActivity\":1665672776000,\"parentId\":13734567,\"originalParentId\":13732350,\"likeCount\":0,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"depth\":0,\"attachments\":[],\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"relations\":\"canReport\":false,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"canEdit\":false,\"canUseDelete\":false,\"isLiked\":false,\"type\":\"comment\",\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"canConvertToAnswer\":false,\"canBeModerated\":false,\"canViewRevisions\":false,\"showInReply\":false,\"reported\":false,\"canCancelReport\":false,\"canDelete\":false,\"canVoteDownOrCancel\":false,\"canComment\":false,\"canViewReports\":false,\"isCurrentUserAuthor\":false,\"liked\":false,\"moderatorComment\":false]}"); const simplifiedQuestionView = JSON.parse("true"); (function() window.pageContext = mergeDeep(pageContext, question: id: 13732350, plug: "edi-changes-with-s4-hana", votes: 1, questionTitle: "EDI Changes with S4 HANA", isClosed: false, isLocked: false, isRedirected: false, redirectedFromTitle: "", redirectedFromId: "", closedStatusData: JSON.parse(""), userVoted: false, relations: JSON.parse("\"canClose\":false,\"canUnredirect\":false,\"canReport\":false,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"canEdit\":false,\"canUseDelete\":false,\"canReopen\":false,\"type\":\"question\",\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"canViewRevisions\":true,\"score\":1,\"canUnlock\":false,\"reported\":false,\"canVoteDownOrCancel\":false,\"canLock\":false,\"canCancelReport\":false,\"canComment\":true,\"isCurrentUserAuthor\":false,\"canViewReports\":false"), isQuestionAccepted: false , childToViewInfo: id: "" , comments: JSON.parse("\"13734441\":\"rootParentId\":13734441,\"commentsCount\":1,\"comments\":[\"body\":\"Hi Lutz,\\nThank you so much for sharing this information. As a part of integration with external systems that still use flat files to convert to IDOC, it would help to share the IDOC structures and indicate the changes that have been made with S/4 HANA ( as you mentioned - new fields introduced ). I was unable to find one that indicated the changes to EDI with additional fields. If you can guide me to a document that may have been created / shared, please let me know\\nThanks a lot for your help\",\"author\":\"username\":\"rzalani1\",\"displayName\":\"Rohit Zalani\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"parentAuthor\":\"username\":\"lutzi3\",\"displayName\":\"Lutz Rosenpflanzer\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"id\":13737202,\"creationDate\":1665672592000,\"activeRevisionId\":14281409,\"lastActivity\":1665672592000,\"parentId\":13734441,\"originalParentId\":13732350,\"likeCount\":1,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"depth\":0,\"attachments\":[],\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"relations\":\"canReport\":false,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"canEdit\":false,\"canUseDelete\":false,\"isLiked\":false,\"type\":\"comment\",\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"canConvertToAnswer\":false,\"canBeModerated\":false,\"canViewRevisions\":false,\"score\":1,\"showInReply\":false,\"reported\":false,\"canCancelReport\":false,\"canDelete\":false,\"canVoteDownOrCancel\":false,\"canComment\":false,\"canViewReports\":false,\"isCurrentUserAuthor\":false,\"liked\":false,\"moderatorComment\":false],\"13734567\":\"rootParentId\":13734567,\"commentsCount\":1,\"comments\":[\"body\":\"Hi Joachim,\\nThank you for your response. As I responded to Lutz, it would be useful for integration teams to share the new fields ( or any field level changes ) that may have been made to SAP's EDI IDOC structures so that these can be shared with these teams. As you suggested, the Custom Code Migration will let you know the changes that you may have to do, but if there are new fields / field changes that may have been made to EDI IDOC structures, it would help to have that information included in the documentation so that teams can assess any impacts to external systems / integrations.\\nRegards\\nRohit Zalani\",\"author\":\"username\":\"rzalani1\",\"displayName\":\"Rohit Zalani\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"parentAuthor\":\"username\":\"vonhunnius\",\"displayName\":\"Joachim von Hunnius\",\"groupIcons\":[\"name\":\"employee\",\"title\":\"This user is an SAP Employee\",\"priority\":21],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"id\":13737203,\"creationDate\":1665672776000,\"activeRevisionId\":14281410,\"lastActivity\":1665672776000,\"parentId\":13734567,\"originalParentId\":13732350,\"likeCount\":0,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"depth\":0,\"attachments\":[],\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"relations\":\"canReport\":false,\"visibility\":\"full\",\"canEdit\":false,\"canUseDelete\":false,\"isLiked\":false,\"type\":\"comment\",\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"canConvertToAnswer\":false,\"canBeModerated\":false,\"canViewRevisions\":false,\"showInReply\":false,\"reported\":false,\"canCancelReport\":false,\"canDelete\":false,\"canVoteDownOrCancel\":false,\"canComment\":false,\"canViewReports\":false,\"isCurrentUserAuthor\":false,\"liked\":false,\"moderatorComment\":false]"), answerPager: answersCount: 3, page: 1, pageSize: 10, pageCount: 1, sort: "votes" , answers: JSON.parse("[ SAP Blogs\\nYou will find more info on the CCM app here: Custom Code Migration ,\"body\":\"In all standard IDocs SAP kept the segments compatible. The old field from ECC (ex. MATNR in segment E1MARAM) still has the old length (C18). This means that existing message exchanges will keep working if the length stays C18 in S/4 as well.\\nAdditionally SAP added new fields with the new length (ex MATNR_LONG in E1MARAM with C40). In the SAP standard scenarios both fields are filled in the outbound and accepted in the inbound.\\nFinally, for Z segments or Z IDocs there is a ATC check being part of the Custom Code Migration Check which lists all IDoc fields of the concerned types / domaines such as MATNR but as well DMBTR or ATWRT and so on.\\nKind Regards\",\"author\":\"username\":\"lutzi3\",\"displayName\":\"Lutz Rosenpflanzer\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"id\":13734441,\"posted\":1665318137000,\"votes\":0,\"isAccepted\":false,\"isLocked\":false,\"userVoted\":\"\",\"relations\":\"canCancelAccept\":false,\"canUnlock\":false,\"canUseDelete\":false,\"canVoteDownOrCancel\":false,\"canLock\":false,\"canAccept\":false,\"type\":\"answer\",\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"isCurrentUserAuthor\":false,\"attachments\":[],\"body\":\"Hi Rohit, \\nYou could start by analysing the differences on the IDoc XML Schema level. Export the definitions from transaction WE60 (e.g. for INVOIC02) and then perform a diff on the XML Schema. This will precisely show you what has changed in the IDoc and what has been amended. \\nHere is for instance an analysis for INVOIC02 -in-s4hana/ \\nPhilipp\",\"author\":\"username\":\"philipp.liegl\",\"displayName\":\"Philipp Liegl\",\"groupIcons\":[],\"suspended\":false,\"isCurrentUser\":false,\"id\":13752876,\"posted\":1667967438000,\"votes\":0,\"isAccepted\":false,\"isLocked\":false,\"userVoted\":\"\",\"relations\":\"canCancelAccept\":false,\"canUnlock\":false,\"canUseDelete\":false,\"canVoteDownOrCancel\":false,\"canLock\":false,\"canAccept\":false,\"type\":\"answer\",\"canVoteUpOrCancel\":false,\"isCurrentUserAuthor\":false,\"attachments\":[]]"), answerForm: formAction: "/answers/13732350/post.json", textareaName: "body", textareaErrors: "", isAttachmentsEnabled: true, answerEditorialGuideline: title: "Before answering", content: "You should only submit an answer when you are proposing a solution to the poster\'s problem. If you want the poster to clarify the question or provide more information, please leave a comment instead, requesting additional details. When answering, please include specifics, such as step-by-step instructions, context for the solution, and links to useful resources. Also, please make sure that your answer complies with our Rules of Engagement.", links: [ title: "Rules of Engagement", href: " -of-engagement.html", ] , answerMinBodyLength: '10', answerMaxBodyLength: '20000' , currentUser: sapInternalId: '', permissions: canVoteUpOrCancel: false, canVoteDownOrCancel: false, canModerate: false, , isVotedUp: false, isVotedDown: false , alerts: alertModeratorMinLength : "It should be given a proper explanation about why the content is inappropriate.", alertModeratorMinLengthValue : "10", alreadyReportedMessage : "You already have an active moderator alert for this content." , url: profileApiBaseUrl: ' -api.services.sap.com', followUnfollowQuestion: '/sap/nodeSubscription.json', isFollowingQuestion: '/sap/isFollowingNode.json', vote: voteUp: '/commands/0/voteup.json', voteDown: '/commands/0/votedown.json', cancelVote: '/commands/0/cancelvote.json' , rss: answers: '/feed/13732350/answers.rss', answersAndComments: '/feed/13732350/comments-and-answers.rss' , authorizeUploadContext: type: 'answer' , atMention: userSearchServiceUrl: ' ', currentUserName: '', useNewUSSCORS: true, atMentionDelayMs: 100, showMentionInRedactor: true , attachmentSettings: commentMaxAttachments: '2', answerMaxAttachments: '10', commentMaxAttachmentSizeBytes: '1048576', answerMaxAttachmentSizeBytes: '1048576', commentAttachmentsSizeBytesTotal: '2097152', answerAttachmentsSizeBytesTotal: '10485760' , editor: editorClipboardUploadEnabled: true ) )(); Home
Community
Ask a Question
Write a Blog Post
Login / Sign-up Search Questions and Answers 1 Rohit Zalani Oct 07, 2022 at 02:26 PM EDI Changes with S4 HANA 206 Views Follow RSS Feed Hi All
Architecting EDI with SAP IDocs.17
2ff7e9595c
Comments